Rafale M, F-35C or F/A-18 Super Hornet Block-3 which one should Indian Navy choose for its 57 fighter requirement?


By: Kartikeya Semwal
We all know that Indian Navy which operates 1 Aircraft Career INS Vikramaditya till date with a couple of Mig-29K fighters; & will soon get its first indigenous Aircraft Career in the next 2-3 years. And for that, it will need new fighter jets to keep up with emerging challenges put up by China’s PLZ Navy in the Indian Ocean region & in Bay of Bengal. New fighters will also be needed to replace the ageing Mig-29Ks on the other aircraft career keeping in mind that China is developing its own aircraft careers that will be well supported by indigenous J-15 & J-20 fighters, the latter of which is a modern day 5th generation stealth jet.
INS Vikramaditya with decked Mig-29Ks & Mi-26 choppers

Indian Navy is gearing up to place an order of 57 fighter planes and a number of jet fighter manufacturing companies from various countries are in the race to get this deal. Now, we all know that India is not going to buy Lockheed Martin’s F-21, nor Eurofighter Typhoon that is considered as a ‘slow & bulky missile truck’. Grippen E offered by Sweden’s Saab isn’t feasible as India’s HAL is itself developing a 4.5 generation MWF (Medium Weight Fighter). That brings the race down to just 3 fighters namely F/A-18 Super Hornet, F-35C being offered by US and Rafale M by France. 
F/A-18 E Super Hornet
Now, 2 out of 3 fighters are costly and this too should be kept in mind by the Indian Navy before placing the order for 57 jet fighters to power its aircraft careers. My take on this is that Indian Navy should go for F/A-18 Super Hornet Block-3. Now you all will think why I didn’t choose Rafale M when IAF (Indian Airforce) has already ordered 36 Rafale jets. The answer is simple, IAF bought the Rafales to counter China’s 5th generation J-20 jets. IAF can further buy another 36 Rafales if needed, but it will come at a big cost. 
F-35C in beast mode 
Another point is that Raafale M has not been battle-tested while US-made F/A-18 Super Hornets have been battle-tested in Iraq & Afghan wars. F-35C too has been battle-tested against IS regime in Iraq & Afghanistan. But it is the most costly aircraft out of all 3. 
Rafale M
An F-35C costs US$108.8 million while an F/A-18 Super Hornet Block-3 costs US$70.5 million and a Rafale M costs US$85million. This means that India can buy 4 Super Hornets under US$300 million while only 3 F-35Cs and 3 Rafale Ms could be brought at US$325+ million. Also, no technology will be given for F-35Cs & only partial technology can be offered for Rafale M, Boeing has offered full TOT if Indian Navy selects F/A-18 Super Hornet Block-3. Now this offer alone is enough to shortlist it for Indian Navy and why not? Also, IAF needs to place an order of 114 medium combat jets. This deal is separate from the 123 fighter jet deal that will be provided by HAL through Tejas Mk-1 & Mark-II LCA (Light Combat Aircrafts). Keeping this factor in mind, if IAF chooses F/A-18 Super Hornet Block-III, it will become a common platform between IAF and Indian Navy. This will bring down the total production, spare parts and maintenance cost for both the forces. Also, India will get access to a lot of much-needed technologies especially the engine technology, IRST & EW (Infrared Satellite Transmission & Electronic Warfare). 
More-so, if IAF orders for a batch of another 36 Rafales, surely it will get access to a certain set of technologies. This way, IAF & Indian Navy can get two different types of 4.5 generation fighters with different sets of technologies. Those technologies can in-turn be used to develop the indigenous MWF fighter which will become the best in its category & better than the rest of 4-4.5 generation fighters. 
Indian Navy can get more Super Hornets when compared to F-35C and Rafale M. And surely, it would need more jets keeping China’s Navy’s threat in mind. The number game does matter.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Indian Navy needs a variety & quantity upgrade in submarines

Image
By: Kartikeya Semwal Conventional submarine  Indian Navy is the world’s 7 th largest navy in the world with 294 warships. While our biggest enemy China is ranked 2 nd largest with 730 warships of different types. This is a cause of concern as we aren’t even half of our enemy. In the last 1 decade, under Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi ji & Raksha mantri Shri Rajnath Singh ji, our navy has added many warships to its fleet, yet a lot more needs to be done. China has a large number of different types of submarines ranging from conventional to nuclear. The advantage that they have is that they are building their own submarines & that too, at a fast pace. Contrast to that India doesn’t makes its own conventional submarines. And there is a huge gap in this category. China has 48 conventional submarines which means that it can deploy as many of them to watch or surround Indian Ocean region (IOR) while India has only 16 conventional submarines. Those too are the old Russian Kilo cl
Read more

Indian Army gearing for major Artillery Upgrade

Image
Indian Army gearing for major Artillery Upgrade By- Kartikeya Semwal Indian Army has been a recognized force across the world. With changing scenarios across the borders and keeping its eastern neighbour in mind, Indian Army is gearing up for a major upgrade of its artillery units. Recently it had brought 100 K9-Vajra self-propelled artillery guns that are of 155*52 calibre. It is going to repeat this order & buy another batch of 100 similar guns with modifications for cold weather & low temperature during winters. K-9 Vajra  Indian Army is also modifying its 21 regiments of 135*45 mm Sharang guns to 155*45 mm. 6 regiments have already been modified while the remaining 15 will be modified in the next 5 years. Besides, Indian Army is also buying indigenous Dhanush towed artillery guns that are of 155*45 mm calibre and can fire APFSD shells to destroy armoured tanks and bunkers of enemies.  Sharang As if this was not enough, Indian Army is also gearing up to buy atleast 150 ATAGS
Read more

Those 21 Mig-29s were needed

Image
  Those 21 Mig-29s were needed  By- Kartikeya Semwal  IAF had signed a deal with the Russian Mig Consortium to purchase 21 Mig-29s to strengthen its air-defense capabilities and increase its number of fighter squadrons. But now that deal has been canceled keeping India’s MWF/Tejas Mk-2 in mind. But one thing that IAF failed to notice is that the 1 st MWF won’t be inducted before 2026, which is far away for now and the 1 st flying squadron of MWF/Tejas Mk-2 won’t appear before 2028-2029 which is way too long keeping IAF’s requirement and Chinese threat in mind.  Mig-29 UPG of IAF Some of the defense experts and analysts have expressed concern with inducting more Russian jets as they can be hacked into and crashed by China’s cyber force. But India has the ability to counter it by installing their own system computers and indigenous radar and EWS (electronic warfare system) on those Mig-29s. Those were also meant to be upgraded in terms of hardware and software. According to me, IAF has
Read more